Answer
In the Name of Allah, Most Gracious, Most Merciful.
All praise and thanks are due to Allah, and peace and blessings be upon His Messenger.
In this fatwa:
- One group of scholars view that it is not permissible for those offering udhiyah to trim their nails or hair; but that there is no restriction on conjugal relations.
- The second group believes that while the trimming of nails or hair is undesirable, it is not forbidden.
- The third group believe that the trimming of nails or hair is permissible. They believe that these restrictions only apply to pilgrims in a state of Ihram.
In responding to your question, Sheikh Ahmad Kutty, a senior lecturer and an Islamic scholar at the Islamic Institute of Toronto, Ontario, Canada, states:
What you mentioned in the question is only one of the views on the issue.
There is another view, which states that such restrictions only apply to those in Ihram. This is what we learn from Aishah, the beloved wife of the Prophet (peace be upon him). She said that the Prophet never observed such restrictions while offering sacrifice in Madinah. It is inconceivable that he would do the opposite of what he instructed.
Consequently, Imam Abu Hanifah and Malik, as well as many other scholar, found no reason to support such prohibitions. They stated that those who intend to offer udhiyah are free to clip their nails and cut their hair. They can also perform other personal grooming routines; unless they are in a state of Ihram for Hajj or Umrah.
To explain the issue in detail, allow me to explain the differences of opinion on this issue. There are three views on the matter.
First View
📚 Read Also: 5 Reasons Why Dhul-Hijjah 10 Days Are Very Special
1- One group thinks it is not permissible for those offering a sacrifice to trim their nails or hair. However, there is no restriction on conjugal relations. They base their opinion on a report attributed to Umm Salamah. The Prophet said; “If you see the crescent of Dhul-Hijjah, those who intend to offer the sacrifice should not shave or trim or remove their hair or nails.” (Muslim)
Based on this, Imam Ahmad and Dawud Azh-Zhahiri and Imam Ash-Shafi`i (in one report) consider it forbidden to do so. While some apply this statement generally, others say it is only for men and not women; but they do so without evidence for such distinction.
Second View
2- The second group believes that while the trimming of nails or hair is undesirable, it is not forbidden. In other words, one would get rewards for refraining from such practices. But he would incur no sin for engaging in them. The Shafities and others who try to strike a middle position in order to reconcile conflicting reports support this position
Third View
3- The third view is that of the Hanafi and Maliki schools. They believe the trimming of nails or hair is permissible. They believe that these restrictions only apply to pilgrims in a state of Ihram. This view is based on explicit evidence from Aishah. She says; “I placed garlands (to mark) the camels dispatched by the Prophet for sacrifice to Makkah; and yet the Prophet (while remaining in Madinah) never abided by any of the restrictions.” In other words, he continued his grooming practices as usual without any inhibition.
The Narration of Aishah
Abu Hanifah, Malik, Al-Layth, and many other scholars, including Ikrimah, Ata ibn Abi Rabah, Salim ibn Abd Allah, Taws, Qasim ibn Muhammad, Ata ibn Yasar, Jabir ibn Zayd, etc.. all consider the hadith of Aishah to be more reliable than that of Umm Salamah. They classify the latter as somewhat weak or questionable.
When Aishah was told that Ibn Abbas was ordering people not to cut their nails or hair if they intended to offer sacrifice, she wrote to him saying to stop issuing such rulings as it contradicted the practice of the Prophet (peace be upon him). Her clear argument was: How could the Prophet have ordered people not to do so when he practised differently?
When the Caliph Mu`awiyah wrote to Aishah asking for clarification on the issue, she reiterated her refutation of restrictions on personal grooming for those intending to offer a sacrifice.
Supporting Arguments
The scholars who support the position of Aishah also offer the following arguments:
The report from Aishah is well attested and transmitted through reliable sources that are beyond doubt. As opposed to this, Imam Ibn Abd al-Barr states that most scholars consider the report attributed to Umm Salamah as weak.
Imam Malik did not even deem it worthy of transmission. Imam Al-Layth (Imam Malik’s colleague who also studied under scholars in Madinah), when asked about the same, stated: “There is a report to that effect; however, we did not see people acting upon it.” He meant that the people of Madinah did not act upon the report since there was more persuasive evidence against it. We would do well to remember that Imam Malik considered continuous practices of the Madinan community as a proof for or against isolated hadith reports.
Rational Analogy
They also use a convincing rational analogy:
On being told of the view that one may not clip nails or hair while intending to sacrifice, Ikrimah (the student of Ibn Abbas, and an eminent scholar) said, “Then why don’t they also stay away from spousal relations and perfume?”
In other words, it does not make sense that the Prophet (peace be upon him) would prohibit the clipping of nails and hair while permitting spousal relations and perfume when we know that violating sanctions against the latter entail higher penalties in a state of Ihram.
Furthermore, in Islamic jurisprudence, a general rule of permissibility applies when there is no clear evidence of restriction.
The scholars who support this view also point out that Aishah’s report relates to a later period in Prophet’s life (peace be upon him): the 9th year of Hijrah, when he sent Abu Bakr as the Amir of Hajj on his behalf.
Once again, it is inconceivable that the Prophet (peace be upon him) would forbid something for others while engaging in it himself. Aishah said about the Prophet (peace be upon him): “If he were to forbid something, he would be the first to stay away from it.” This is one of the statements on the Prophet (peace be upon him) in the Quran: “And I do not intend to differ from you in that which I have forbidden you.” (Hud 11: 88)
Before concluding, I must point out that those who support the position of permission in this matter include – besides Abu Hanifah and Al-Layth – the following eminent scholars: Ikrimah, Ata ibn Abi Rabah, Salim ibn Abd Allah, Taws, Qasim ibn Muhammad, Ata ibn Yasar, Jabir ibn Zayd, etc.
In conclusion, the ruling allowing the clipping of hair and nails is far more reliable, reasonable and convincing.
Almighty Allah knows best.