Ads by Muslim Ad Network

Second Wife: My Son and I Are Neglected

21 August, 2024
Q As-Salamu Alaikom. I have been married for six years. At the time, a man proposed to me who I suddenly fell in love with, but I was not told that he was already married until I found it out by myself after our marriage. I forgave him for that when he admitted and overlooked as I understood that he just didn't have the courage to tell his family about me, not even his mother; only his sister knows about me.I have a five-year-old son from him. However, I cannot bear anymore being alone all the time rearing and disciplining my child who is a boy. For 3 to 4 months a year, he is not able to see his father because my husband has gone home to his first family. He is having a twelve-year-old boy there. I feel that I and my son are completely neglected by him. I even asked him to come for at least one Jumuah ( Friday) to take our son to the masjid, but it has never happened. Many times, I was thinking to go to the Family Guidance Division to ask for divorce, but he would always remind me of the hadith regarding a woman not smelling the fragrance of heaven if she would ask for divorce. But then I remember Surah an-Nisa and its verses regarding the rights of a wife and her child.Please, help me. Are his actions towards me and my son unjust? I am tired emotionally and mentally aside from the fact that I work full time the whole day, and at home I am all alone for my son's needs. On top of that, I am financially helpless; when I don't ask him, he would not give us from his salary even though he is a company's leading engineer. I have a well-paid job, but I always receive my salary late by 2 or 3 months, and I also maintain my mother's health by sending money from my income on a monthly basis. Am I abused? Please, help me out. Jazakallah Khair.

Answer

Answer:

Wa ‘Alaykum As-Salam,

The disappointment you have been experiencing is definitely normal. In general, I would say that from most people’s perspective, what this man, your husband, is doing is truly not fair at all. First, I must explain to you that I am not a Scholar of Islamic Jurisprudence. I am a psychologist. To answer the technical question of whether you would be eligible for divorce according to Sharia law, I highly recommend that you utilize our expert scholars. I certainly believe that much of the anxiety about your rights as a woman will be relieved if you do, in sha’ Allah.

As a human being and as a woman, I am heartbroken to hear that you are being treated like this. It hurts even more to now that a father is refusing to take responsibility for the welfare and healthy upbringing of his son. As a psychologist and community builder, I am worried about the health of family systems which are the foundation of a community.

You asked if you are being abused. A man who does not fulfill his responsibilities towards his family giving the best of his ability is abusing his family. So yes, this neglect seems abusive to me. But what I intuitively want to target as a psychologist and community builder is communication; the lack of connection between you and this man’s family, the fact that the two of you did not discuss how you would make your lives work, and how you would divide your shared responsibilities for the family and household that you agreed to co-create are areas worth investigating. Is this inability to communicate effectively so that you can optimally co-create a mutually satisfying situation which is not only good for both of you, but is also in the best interest of the children, something that you can improve? Since you did not set the foundation prior to your marriage for sustainable stability of the emotional, financial, practical, psychological, and spiritual needs of your son, is your husband willing to work with you to find a way to co-parent and get those needs for your son now?  Even if you divorce, this man, who is the father of this young child, has a responsibility for his welfare.

With all this said, for now, get some counseling for yourself.  You must take care of yourself so that you can evoke the necessary energy that will help you to provide for your son. There is no hurry for divorce.  Just getting a divorce probably won’t really solve the actual issues that are confronting you. It does not mean that you do not have the right to divorce, or that in the long run a divorce will help you. But for now, you should focus on the first few basic steps of real survival so that your son can experience stability and emotional safety.

Those first steps include, as I mentioned, getting some counseling in order to balance your busy schedule and complicated financial situation, stabilizing your emotions, remaining “present” for your son, and providing a healthy and stable environment for him. This also includes reaching out to family and friends and developing a support network system for yourself not to be alone in your parenting and also as a woman. Once you have that in place, the next step is to get marriage counseling if your husband is willing to attend. You can then work on your communication issues, find out what he really wants, and see if you both have compatible goals and are able to provide mutual support for each other – even if you want to walk down the road of separation and divorce while working out a co-parenting plan. It simply does not make sense that a man not only refuses to divorce a woman, but also refuses to be a husband, a father and an active participant in family life. Counseling can help you both to sort out these issues.

Ads by Muslim Ad Network

I pray that these insights will be helpful to you. I continue to encourage you to ask your questions from our Shari’ah experts as well so that you are well informed. Do not forget to pray to Allah for guidance.  All of the outer sources of guidance that you receive (including mind) are simply general insights for you to consider as you seek your inner guidance that is given to you by Allah to uncover the best path for you and your son.

May your future be blessed and bright.

***

Disclaimer: The conceptualization and recommendations stated in this response are very general and purely based on the limited information that was provided in the question. In no event shall AboutIslam, it’s volunteers, writers, scholars, counselors, or employees be held liable for any direct, indirect, exemplary, punitive, consequential or other damages whatsoever that may arise through your decision or action in the use of the services which our website provides. 

About Dr. Bachmeier
Dr. Bachmeier is a clinical psychologist who has been working in the mental health field for over 15 years. She is also a former adjunct professor at Argosy University, writer, and consultant in the areas of mental health, cultural, and relationship issues.