Are Bank Transfers That Require a Fee Permissible?

22 November, 2020
Q I went to a bureau de change in Tripoli and asked them to transfer $15,000 to Dubai. They asked me to give them the $15,000 in addition to 150 dinars, on the basis that this was a transfer fee. Is this transaction permissible? Please give a detailed answer.

Answer

In the Name of Allah, Most Gracious, Most Merciful.

All praise and thanks are due to Allah, and peace and blessings be upon His Messenger.


In this fatwa:

The fee that is charged by the bank in return for transferring the money is permissible, whether it is a percentage of the amount transferred or is a fixed fee.


In responding to your question, the Fatwa Center at Islam Q and A, states:

What is bank transfer?

This kind of service or bank transaction is called a transfer (hawalah). Scholars define hawalah as instructions from a bank or financial institution, at the customer’s request, to another bank or financial institution in the same country or elsewhere – and it may be a branch of the same bank – so that the bank to which the transfer is made will pay a certain amount of money to a specific, named individual. The transfer procedure usually involves changing from one currency to another.

In the bank transfer a loan?

This bank transfer is not a loan given to the bank by the customer, and it is not hawalah in the technical, fiqhi sense, which refers to transferring a debt owed to one person to another person. The customer’s aim in this transaction is to transfer money that is in his possession to that particular place; he appoints the bank or financial institution to transfer it and pays a fee for that transfer.

In the transfer fee permissible?

Sheikh Dr. Yusuf Ash-Shubayli (may Allah preserve him) said:

“The fee that the customer pays to the bank is permissible, because it is in return for the bank acting on behalf of the customer in transferring his money to the other city or country. Transferring the money is the purpose of this procedure from the outset, and the fee is not in return for hawalah [transfer of debt] or a loan.

With regard to it not being in return for hawalah [transfer of debt], that is because the customer does not intend to transfer payment of a loan that he gave to the bank to which the money is transferred, as is indicated by the fact that hawalah in the technical, fiqhi sense is intended to help the one who asks for the debt to be transferred, therefore the request to transfer the debt comes from the debtor, so he is the one who asks the lender to transfer the debt to a third party.

In the case of a bank transfer, however, the request comes from the lender (the one who is transferring the money). With regard to the fee not being in return for a loan, that is because in this case it is the bank that is borrowing, not the lender. The fee that is not permissible according to Islamic teaching is the fee that the lender charges.

Based on that, the fee that the banks charges in return for transferring the money is permissible. This applies whether it is a percentage of the amount transferred or is a fixed fee.” (Fiqh al-Mu‘amalaat al-Masrafiyyah, 32)

We read in Qararat Majma‘ al-Fiqh al-Islami (1/88 – ninth session):

“With regard to transfers in which money is paid in one currency, and the one requesting the transfer wants to transfer it in the same currency, that is permissible according to Islamic teachings, whether that is done for no fee or is done in return for a reasonable fee.

📚 Read Also: Is It Permissible to Open a Bank Checking Account?

If it is done in return for a fee, it is to be regarded as appointing someone to do something in return for a fee. If those who do these transfers work for people in general [i.e., not only for one person], then they are liable for the money they transfer, in accordance with the principle that a person who is hired to do work for many people is liable.”

Almighty Allah knows best.

Source: www.islamqa.info