In this counseling answer:
“The counselor advises the questioner that At this age of her kids, there is no harm in them playing together in the tub. She may find that her daughter will become curious about her little brother’s private parts as well as her own. This is normal and if she does not make a big deal out of it and just tell her that Allah made boys and girls different it should suffice. But if she concerned she can separate them slowly at first, maybe give her son a bath, then her daughter, then the next day bathe them together and keep switching up until they are bathing separately most of the time.”
As salamu alaykum,
Thank you for writing to us. I remember my children at those ages playing in the tub with bubbles and toys and these are indeed good memories! These are times when siblings bond and have much fun. At this age, there is no harm in them playing together in the tub.
While your 3 years old may notice her sibling looks different, it may not be an issue unless she wants to touch his private parts or becomes overly inquisitive to the point wherein it is a distraction at bath time. As long as they are having fun and are not preoccupied with private parts there is no harm.
While I am not an Islamic scholar I can only advise you based on my own experiences as a mom as well as other parent’s experiences. As children develop at different rates within developmental stages, you may soon find that your daughter will become curious about her little brother’s private parts as well as her own. This is normal sister and if you do not make a big deal out of it and just tell her that Allah made boys and girls different it should suffice.
Check out this counseling answer
Don’t make her feel bad or guilty for being curious, but when she does begin to get curious you may want to ask her if she would like privacy when she baths as she is becoming a “big girl”. If she doesn’t want separate baths, you can start the separation process anyhow in increments.
I would kindly suggest separating them slowly at first, maybe give your son a bath, then her, then the next day bathe them together and keep switching up until they are bathing separately most of the time.
I suggest this method only because their bathing is a fun time and is innocent to them. Suddenly separating them may cause some confusion and resistance, especially from your daughter as they are used to their fun bath times together.
Additionally, her little brother may also miss their playtime and wonder where his sister is. Therefore by slowing changing from bathing together to bathing separately, you will decrease the feelings of their missing each other by getting them used to bathe alone first without totally taking away their together fun time until they have transitioned separately.
Sister, I do not feel you have to worry about this right now however when natural curiosity and direct physical play involving private parts occurs (if it does) then it will be time to start separating bath time. For now, enjoy their bath time with them as these are cherishing moments!
Disclaimer: The conceptualization and recommendations stated in this response are very general and purely based on the limited information that was provided in the question. In no event shall AboutIslam, it’s volunteers, writers, scholars, counselors, or employees be held liable for any direct, indirect, exemplary, punitive, consequential or other damages whatsoever that may arise through your decision or action in the use of the services which our website provides.