He was born disabled yet he worked hard. He was a pious, very pious, kind, kind, kind, kind, kind, very innocent angel. He kissed ami and abu forehead daily. All he wanted was to live a happy life, and Allah took him; he begged for life. Allah took him and gave him so much pain and misery in the end. I am losing faith, all is a lie.
Answer
In this counseling answer:
- When we grieve, we experience intense feelings. There are different stages and emotional experiences that we may go through before we eventually reach some kind of peace with our loss. It is common that you may shift between complete denial and anger, questioning why this happened.
- We do not know why things happen in a particular way. But perhaps, if we could see the bigger picture, we would understand why things happened this way.
Assalamu Alaikum, sister,
Thank you for your letter. I am truly sorry to hear about your pain and the loss of your dear brother, who has just passed away.
I am sure that he is deeply missed by your entire family, and that his absence is felt by all of you. This must be a very difficult, hard, and painful situation for everyone right now.
As a result, you find yourself questioning Islam, questioning your faith, and questioning the Quran. Which, from the perspective of the stages of grief, is quite understandable.
When we grieve, we experience intense feelings. There are different stages and emotional experiences that we may go through before we eventually reach some kind of peace with our loss. It is common that you may shift between complete denial and anger, questioning why this happened. Perhaps you are looking for someone to blame, someone who is responsible for what happened. In your case, it seems that it is Islam and Allah. Intense sadness and hopelessness are also part of this process.
I know that right now it may be difficult to see things differently, but I want you to know that eventually, insha’Allah, you may be able to understand this as part of his destiny and perhaps as part of his test, as well as your family’s test.
We will all be tested with loss…
And when you say that the Quran is a lie, I would just like to remind you that it is precisely in the Quran that we find the verse in which Allah promises us that we will be tested with loss, fear, and hardship, and gives glad tidings to those who are patient:
“We will certainly test you with a touch of fear and famine and loss of property, life, and crops. Give good news to those who patiently endure—who say, when struck by a disaster, “Surely to Allah we belong and to Him we will ˹all˺ return.” (2:155-156)
Patience here does not simply mean waiting. It also means being able to endure this period and understanding that everything happens within Allah’s knowledge and decree.
Perhaps it is also worth reflecting on the story of Khidr and Musa (peace be upon them). It teaches us that sometimes we do not know the full picture. We do not know why things happen in a particular way, but perhaps, if we could see the bigger picture, we would understand why things happened this way.
Perhaps your brother was protected from something, or perhaps you and your family were prevented from experiencing an even greater tragedy. Who knows? I really don’t know, but try to look at things from this perspective: the full picture and the entire story of our lives are unknown to us. Your brother was taken away in this way, but who knows what might have happened to him otherwise, something that could have been even worse or more painful?
So, I don’t know how your family is dealing with this, but I hope you can share your grief, support one another, and be there for each other. Meanwhile, you can still maintain your connection with him. You can keep him in your heart and in your thoughts. You can still allow yourself to express your feelings. For example, by writing down what you wanted to say to him, but could not. You can also make du’a for him, or to give charity on his behalf too.
He will remain part of your family, your family history, and your shared narrative for a long, long time to come, insha’Allah.
May Allah make things easy for you.
