I have no answers to your questions. Your questions are based on speculations. In other words, you are stating hypothesizes and speculations as if they were proven scientific facts. Facts are facts; they cannot be confused with opinions based on conjecture. Allah says: “And [since] they have no knowledge whatever thereof, they follow nothing but surmise: yet, behold, never can surmise take the place of truth” (Qur’an 53:28).

 

Therefore, I do not agree with your assumptions with regard to the sacrifice of Adam’s sons.

 

2- As for the second question, you forget the central message of the verse: That Prophets are not angels or divine beings; rather they are mortals who are not above the fundamental norms and customs of the people of their time.  So, the mention of walking in the markets should not be taken to mean as if they were walking the modern shopping malls; humans are social beings, and as such, they would congregate and interact and exchange goods, etc. So, there is no reason to deny this Quranic assertion.

 

3- Likewise, the Qur’an’s teaching on charity is intended to address situations where there are poverty and suffering. It does not apply to a utopian or ideal state where everyone is self-sufficient, and hence there is no question of poverty.